Quick Summary: Smart Realty is a solid fit for most Perth landlords who value an all-inclusive fee, hands-on management by licensee Mahi Masud, and careful compliance with the Residential Tenancy Act 1987. Its reviews are mostly positive, but the evidence is limited: Trustpilot rates it 3.5 out of 5 from only 15 reviewers, while other platforms show stronger ratings and testimonials. Communication delays and key-person risk deserve attention, so landlords should ask about response times and backup staffing before signing.
Searching Smart Realty investment properties reviews turns up three different numbers: a 3.5 out of 5 TrustScore on Trustpilot from 15 reviewers, a 5.0 star rating on domain.com.au, and warm owner testimonials on realestate.com.au. Which should a landlord trust? This review weighs the evidence, checks the ratings against Perth fee data, and shows what the small print on fees, bond handling and licensee involvement really means.
What Smart Realty Investment Property Reviews Actually Say
Smart Realty’s reviews split by platform. Trustpilot sits at 3.5 out of 5 from 15 reviews, domain.com.au shows 5.0 stars, and realestate.com.au carries owner testimonials. So the honest answer is mostly positive sentiment on a small base, not a runaway score on either side.

Reading the Trustpilot, domain.com.au and realestate.com.au Scores Together
Treat the numbers as one picture, not three verdicts. The Trustpilot profile shows a 3.5 TrustScore from just 15 reviews, so one or two unhappy clients swing it hard. domain.com.au’s 5.0 stars and realestate.com.au testimonials lean the other way. Boutique agencies always carry smaller bases, which is why review transparency matters more than a single headline score.
The Complaint Pattern: Communication and Response Times
Where criticism appears, it clusters around two themes: communication lapses and slow responses to maintenance or tenant queries. Neither points to bond handling or rent arrears trouble. Ask any manager directly how they log and answer owner requests, because a fifteen-review sample rewards exactly that kind of question.
Fees, Compliance and What Landlords Actually Receive
What All-Inclusive Actually Removes From Your Bill
How much does Smart Realty charge? It uses a single all-inclusive management fee with no hidden fees, rather than stacking separate charges for inspections, statements or lease renewals. That matters because Perth management fees typically run 8 to 12 percent of collected rent, with some agencies charging up to 12.75 percent, and add-ons push the real total higher. An all-inclusive fee, benchmarked against the WA market range, makes year-one costs predictable before you sign.

Residential Tenancy Act 1987 Compliance as a Landlord Safeguard
Strict compliance with the Residential Tenancy Act 1987 protects you where cheap fees often fail: correct rent increases, lawful notices, bond handling and dispute avoidance. Non-compliance risks tribunal orders and unpaid rent, which cost far more than any management fee saving. When you compare Perth property managers, check both fee structure and compliance practice. Licensee Mahi Masud oversees this work personally rather than outsourcing it, so reviews reflect the person who manages your property.
Pros and Cons of Choosing Smart Realty
The main drawbacks are a 3.5 TrustScore on Trustpilot, a small review base of 15, boutique capacity limits, and key-person risk around Mahi Masud.

Where Smart Realty Clearly Wins
Mahi Masud’s licensee-led management means strict compliance with the Residential Tenancy Act 1987. The all-inclusive fee has no hidden add-ons, unlike typical Perth agencies charging 8 to 12 percent plus extras. Reviews on domain.com.au praise hands-on property maintenance coordination and consistent rent collection.
Where Landlords Should Look Twice
That 3.5 TrustScore rests on only 15 reviews, so one or two complaints swing it hard. As a boutique agency, Smart Realty takes fewer properties than franchise-style competitors, and service depends heavily on one licensee. Ask directly about backup staffing before signing.
Is Smart Realty Worth It for Perth Landlords?
Yes, for most Perth landlords. Smart Realty suits investors who want an all-inclusive fee with no hidden add-ons and hands-on licensee management under the Residential Tenancy Act 1987. It fits less well if you want a large franchise network or a big online review base, since only 15 Trustpilot reviews exist.
Who Should Choose Smart Realty and Who Should Look Elsewhere
Choose Smart Realty if you own one or two rentals and value direct access to Mahi Masud, property management that follows the Act closely, and transparent pricing. Larger Perth agencies may suit owners wanting big-brand systems instead.

Weighing a switch? Talk through your property with Smart Realty. Expect straight answers, one all-inclusive fee, and licensee Mahi Masud personally overseeing your investment from day one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Are Smart Realty investment properties reviews trustworthy?
Mostly yes, but check the base. Trustpilot shows 3.5 from only 15 reviews, while domain.com.au shows 5.0 stars, so small samples swing easily.
Q2: What does the all-inclusive fee cover?
Inspections, statements and lease renewals, with no hidden add-ons, unlike Perth’s typical 8 to 12 percent plus extras.
Q3: Who manages my property day to day?
Licensee Mahi Masud oversees management personally under the Residential Tenancy Act 1987, so ask about backup staffing before you sign.
Conclusion
Reviews across Trustpilot, domain.com.au and realestate.com.au point one way: mostly positive sentiment on a small base. For Perth landlords, Smart Realty’s all-inclusive fee, strict Residential Tenancy Act 1987 compliance and hands-on licensee management outweigh the thin review count.